- If I think the book is crappy, I'll say so, not be silent.
- Why should I have to pay to return a review copy? That's not how the world works.
- Can Andy enforce the bribe/contract?
- What if it backfires and people request review copies just so they can write negative reviews?
Michael N. Marcus discusses writing, editing, publishing and sometimes other things. He often draws attention to inept publishers and writers. It's his duty and his compulsion. It's important and often funny. If you present work to the public, you must be able to withstand criticism. If your feelings get hurt easily, keep your work private. When you seek praise, you risk derision. In publishing, either produce pro-quality work by yourself or get help from qualified professionals.
Saturday, February 4, 2012
Literary corruption
From author Andy Duncan: "I’ll even be giving away the first 20 copies to anyone prepared to write a five-star review on Amazon. (If you feel it’s unworthy of that, just send me the book back again, and forget you ever saw it.)"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

His wording is strange. I'm "prepared" to write a five-star review, although that doesn't mean I will.
ReplyDelete"Literary corruption" Great title. I have no respect for writers who do not have a moral ground how they obtain reviews. Thank you for the heads up. I will make a point to avoid this writer's work. Some writers purchase reviews from literary services and pass them off to friends and family plus post them online including on Amazon as if they are real unsolicited reviews.
ReplyDeleteI haven't posted comments lately but I always enjoy your website.